American Military Members Are Getting Brutally Honest About Marines Being Deployed To Los Angeles

0
381

As the protests in Los Angeles against ICE continue, the Trump administration announced it would be sending in 2,000 additional National Guard soldiers as well as 700 active duty Marines. According to Reuters, they will "protect federal personnel and property" as the administration carries out "even more operations to round up suspected immigration violators."

A person in a suit and tie is sitting at a desk, appearing to speak or engage in conversation
Anna Moneymaker / Getty Images

Governor Gavin Newsom has filed a lawsuit against the Trump administration, claiming that the president did not have the legal authority to call in the National Guard, as well as requested a temporary restraining order to stop the use of the National Guard and active Marines "for law enforcement purposes."

This is the first time that active duty military members have been called up to assist with law enforcement since 1992, and unsurprisingly, many of them (as well as veterans) have thoughts on the topic. NotSlayerOfDemons asked, "Those in the American Armed Forces, how do you feel about troops being used to quell unrest in-country?" and service members, both active and former, did not hold back in these 28 responses:

1."Former Army. Unrest is when the citizens are trying to send a message to the government. Using troops against your citizens is the government's way of not listening."

A person holds a sign reading "MARINES!! Where Were U JAN 6" facing a line of police officers in riot gear on a city street at night
RINGO CHIU / AFP via Getty Images

—cobra7

2."Marine here. (Once a Marine, always.) Iraq vet. I definitely do not agree with using the Marines. Hopefully, they used MPs with riot training, but using infantry to do police work is not smart. It's like trying to use a trained attack dog to herd sheep. What do you think those teenagers are going to do when someone starts throwing rocks at them?"

—Nevada_Lawyer

3."USAF veteran. We swear an oath to the Constitution. Not to any regime, party, or person."

—chiksahlube

4."Trump is creating his Reichstag fire. Take the time to look this up if you aren’t familiar with it."

Car engulfed in flames on a street with a crowd holding flags and watching from the background
Carlin Stiehl / Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

—RuralMNGuy

(The Reichstag fire was a fire that burned down the Reichstag building, which housed the German parliament, in 1933. The origins of the fire remain unclear, but it became propaganda for Hitler's Nazi government, and he used it to issue the Reichstag Fire Decree, restricting free speech, freedom of the press, and allowing him to begin arresting members of the opposition parties.)

5."As a Marine vet, this fucking sucks. These kids are 18–22 years old and don't know shit about what the Constitution allows or what the Posse Comitatus Act is. They are taught enough not to harm an unarmed civilian, but decades of training for combating guerrilla warfare makes people jumpy. If protesters start throwing Molotov cocktails, or god forbid shooting, then shit gets real for these kids quick. I am afraid that if anything happens, it's going to put a black eye on the Corps that will never be forgotten by the American public."

—Maikudono

6."As a vet, I will say it comes across as totalitarian. There is no reason to use active duty military against your own citizens. There's a great quote from Battlestar Galactica: 'The police and the military have always been separate for a reason. One serves and protects the people, the other fights enemies of the state. When the military does both, the enemies of the state tend to become the people.'"

—Ok-Student7803

7."Army veteran and a SoCal native of 30 years here. Glad to see the president not allowing California to burn to the ground. Everyone knows the governor wasn't going to intervene."

Two men in formal attire stand at a podium outdoors, with one speaking into a microphone, appearing focused and attentive
Justin Sullivan / Getty Images

—ChinMuscle

8."Man, that makes me think of the saying 'When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.' That's the really scary part of having the military do the policing, isn't it?"

—kkeiper1103

9."Telling soldiers to stand on the street with weapons drawn doesn't quell unrest. It provokes unrest."

—timf3d

10."Honorably discharged Army veteran here (Gulf War era). I can say that I and my fellow vet friends think that these troop deployments are fucking terrible. Horrifying, actually."

Members of the California National Guard stand in a line, equipped with protective gear and shields displaying the organization’s name
Bloomberg / Bloomberg via Getty Images

—PSadair

11."This is what the National Guard is for. Putting active duty military personnel on the streets of America to play policeman is a mistake."

—RC10B5M

12."I served in the Marines, and I’m glad I don’t have to sit there and think, 'Question the legality of this and get an NJP [Non-Judicial Punishment], or go and potentially be put in a situation where they’ll have me on trial in The Hague in a few years…'"

"Sooner or later, for everyone, the uniform comes off, and those guys are going to have a hell of a time integrating back into civilian society, even if they end up doing nothing while there."

—Bureaucratic_Dick

13."I'm not active, but former military. I think it's wrong. It's an overreach on presidential power. Plus, it's hard enough getting the everyday American to support our troops these days without deploying them to attack our own civilians."

Aerial view of a large protest on a city street with demonstrators and police vehicles. Protesters hold signs, facing a line of military vehicles
Anadolu / Anadolu via Getty Images

—crash218579

14."Retired Marine here. There are units in the military trained for this. Active duty infantry units are not those units. They can say all they want that they are trained in de-escalation, but in reality, it’s maybe one to two days of training a year and maybe some rapid last-minute refreshers as soon as they found out they were getting sent to LA. The bulk of their training and instincts are to destroy the enemy. This will not go well."

—RonWill79

15."Former Army here — it's complete bullshit. Let law enforcement enforce the law, let the military do military operations. To be honest, they were waiting for any reason to do this because they want to 'send a message,' but the message that's sent isn't what they think it is. I feel sorry for those soldiers sleeping on the hard floor with no plan of provisions for water/food, not abroad in a war zone, but in downtown fucking LA."

—mcstevied

16."Former Marine, from Los Angeles, from immigrant parents. Fuck this administration. I hope those troops remember their oath to the US Constitution and to the people of the nation. I’m so disappointed with this whole situation."

Police in tactical gear with paintball guns stand in a smoky area, appearing prepared for a crowd control situation
Jason Armond / Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

—Tacos_and_Yut

17."I think following the orders of a 34-count felon who is responsible for attacking the Capitol of the USA is reprehensible. I sincerely regret my service to the USA and wish I could take it back. It will not happen again."

—TheDwellingHeart

18."I don't support violent protests. I also don't support Marines being used to quell said protests. Marines are a tool you use to destroy an area or group of people, not to peacefully resolve it. The guard makes more sense here, but the best answer is just keeping it at the police level."

—Well__shit

19."GWOT [Global War on Terrorism] veteran here. This shit is absolutely wack. The United States has used the National Guard MANY times throughout its history, albeit for civil unrest or not. The National Guard does an impeccable job at this, and to hear the National Guard is being utilized isn’t too concerning."

A desert military training area with buildings, vehicles, and a soldier walking down a dirt path; mountains visible in the background
David McNew / Getty Images

"The VERY large, stomach-churning moment is the president giving the green light to utilize 2/7 out of Twentynine Palms. These are not 'peacekeepers.' Their motto is fucking literally 'First to Fight.' They have a long history of intense combat operations from WWII, Korea, Vietnam, Desert Storm, and GWOT. This is a highly decorated combat unit within the US military’s arsenal.

Pitting young, war-fighting men against the people they thought they were protecting is going to be a disastrous clusterfuck."

—NSTalley

20."I support the National Guard being used to protect federal buildings and to quell riots and obstruction to the enforcement of federal law."

—Bravelakes

21."Served in the Navy from '09–'13. The bulk of these guys have never deployed, which is a badge of honor. Young, untested 18–22 year olds with guns seems like a really bad idea to me."

—anthonyajh

22."As a veteran I am pissed that I spent four years defending this country only to have some idiots vote for and support a Christo-fascist government and despite all evidence still believe this is going to be a 'good' thing."

Group of police in riot gear face a protester holding a U.S. flag, engaging in a tense standoff
DAVID PASHAEE / Middle East Images/AFP via Getty Images

—MediocreDecking

23."Retired Navy here and also a former Marine. Sending an infantry battalion (2/7) to assist the LAPD and the National Guard is the wrong move. There are whole-ass battalions of military police who are specifically trained for this scenario. Why weren’t they sent? Every active duty/veteran I know is against this."

—Baker_Kat68

24."It's a complicated issue. Most service members take their oath to defend the Constitution seriously, which includes the rights of Americans to protest. Using the military for domestic unrest should be an absolute last resort, not the go-to option. We're trained to engage enemies, not fellow citizens."

"Many of us feel deep discomfort at the idea of turning our training inward. Peace, order, and public safety are crucial, but so is trust between the people and their government! And nothing erodes that faster than boots on home soil in situations that call for dialogue, not force."

—Emotional_Ticket_357

25."Marine here, many of the brothers and sisters I served with came from immigrant families and communities in LA or ones just like them. I’m sure there’s a few Marines who are on board with this crap, but many are really struggling with this, I can guarantee you."

Soldiers in military gear stand alert with rifles near military vehicles. A building with a "No Emergency Services" sign is in the background
Spencer Platt / Getty Images

—skamatiks671

26."Nobody likes the idea that this administration is attempting to politicize the military. It's awkward for us. The way the Secretary of Defense talks is vile, unprofessional, and embarrassing. Recruiting and retention will plummet."

—220solitusma

27."It's an accident waiting to happen."

Protesters holding signs about immigration face police officers. Signs include messages like "Immigrants make America great" and "Stop separating families."
Mario Tama / Getty Images

—kozmo30

28.And finally, "Real take, most of them don't particularly care and just want to do their job and go home, regardless of the situation. Marines are people and lean slightly right — so you do have people who are giddy about 'enforcing order' — but nobody wants to be dressed up in full kit in LA summer heat."

—HerrArado

Search
Categories
Read More
Health
https://www.facebook.com/GetPowerDropsMaleEnhancement/
Power Drops Male Enhancement👇❗❗Shop...
By UKTodayHealth 2025-02-19 13:37:38 0 932
Crafts
Adjustable Leashes to Suit All Adventures and Sizes
Discover the perfect blend of strength and style with our China Pet Leash collection, now...
By jojo0205 2025-05-22 09:37:28 0 1K
Art
Exploring Noida Sector 18 Call Girls: Luxury and Discretion
Noida Sector 18, one of the most happening and vibrant commercial hubs in the National...
By alishaverma295 2025-02-01 09:01:54 0 1K
Networking
Next Generation Integrated Circuits Market
Next Generation Integrated Circuit Market Analysis The global next generation integrated...
By mrfr1122 2023-11-21 05:28:22 0 3K
News
Iranian Navy “Pulls Out” Capsized Frigate IRIS Sahand That Had Sunk In Port Of Bandar Abbas – Reports
After a painstaking salvage operation spanning several days, Iran has reportedly succeeded in...
By Ikeji 2024-07-23 05:58:51 0 2K