Ukraine’s Military Will “Collapse” Without Starlink Internet, Musk Says; IAF Expert Decodes Elon’s Claims

0
778
 

A public spat erupted between Polish Foreign Minister Radoslaw Sikorski and US Secretary of State Marco Rubio & Elon Musk.

The spat began when Sikorski stated that Poland funds Ukraine’s access to Starlink, which delivers vital internet connectivity to Kyiv and its armed forces.

He alleged that Elon Musk intended to deactivate Starlink terminals in Ukraine, prompting a heated reaction from both Rubio and Musk.

The pair swiftly rejected Sikorski’s assertions about the potential shutdown of Starlink services. Rubio accused the Polish minister of fabricating claims and criticized Ukraine for appearing ungrateful.

Sikorski suggested that Ukraine might need to seek alternatives to Musk’s Starlink if its reliability faltered, while emphasizing the need to be grateful for the support provided so far.

Rubio clarified, “No one has threatened to disconnect Ukraine from Starlink,” adding, “They should say thank you, because without Starlink, Ukraine likely would have lost the war long ago, and Russian forces would be at Poland’s border by now.”

Musk responded, claiming that Poland only pays a “small fraction” of the cost for Ukraine’s Starlink access.

“Be quiet, small man. You pay a tiny fraction of the cost,” Musk said. “And there is no substitute for Starlink,” Musk warned that the entire front line in Ukraine would collapse if he shut off Starlink services.

Earlier, in a post on X, Elon Musk said that no matter how much he disagreed on Ukraine policy, Starlink would never turn off its terminals. “Exactly! To be extremely clear, no matter how much I disagree with the Ukraine policy, Starlink will never turn off its terminals. I am simply stating that, without Starlink, the Ukrainian lines would collapse, as the Russians can jam all other communications! We would never do such a thing or use it as a bargaining chip,” wrote Elon Musk.

AfriPrime App link:  FREE to download...

https://www.amazon.com/Africircle-AfriPrime/dp/B0D2M3F2JT

What If Starlink If Turned Off?

Traditional terrestrial and satellite communication (SATCOM) networks cannot match the bandwidth that Starlink offers. Additionally, most conventional SATCOM systems rely on geostationary satellites, which introduce higher latency, limiting the effectiveness of real-time applications such as remote piloting of UAVs.

Most importantly, Starlink’s low-earth orbit (LEO) satellite architecture makes it more resilient to jamming and provides a more secure communication channel than traditional SATCOM solutions.

Russian EW Capabilities

The Russian military possesses comprehensive, multilayered, and multi-domain electronic warfare capabilities in the world, using an array of short, medium, long, and ultra-long-range systems to effect throughout the course of the proxy war with NATO in Ukraine.

However, Starlink signals from any point on the globe can be routed through many different alternative satellite-based pathways. Additionally, Starlink has proven resilient due to its narrow-beam signals, encrypted data, and SpaceX’s rapid software updates to counter jamming attempts.

Russia’s strategy to degrade Starlink communication has so far been based on attacking Starlink terminals rather than jamming them.

The Russian Borshchevik tactical EW system scans for radio signals emitted by Starlink terminals, which operate on Ku-band frequencies (12–18 GHz) to communicate with low Earth orbit (LEO) satellites.

It can reportedly detect Starlink terminals within a range of up to 10 kilometers and pinpoint their location with an accuracy of 5 to 60 meters (16 to 196 feet).

Borshchevik is vehicle-mounted, powered by either a compact power source or the vehicle’s electrical system, and features a modern graphical interface for real-time data processing, mapping, and topographic analysis.

Once located, Starlink terminals can be attacked using FPV drones or other precision-guided munitions.

Russia’s Tobol EW system, which can jam satellite uplinks or GPS signals, complements Borshchevik’s detection capability.

tobol EW system
Tobol EW system

As part of the ongoing electronic warfare (EW) cat-and-mouse game, Ukrainian forces have adapted by shielding Starlink terminals in pits or using metal mesh to reduce detection and jamming risks.

While the exact effectiveness of Russia’s EW systems remains unclear, Ukraine has acknowledged that Starlink jamming has had an impact.

Ukrainian Minister of Digital Transformation Mykhailo Fedorov told The New York Times that Russia is deploying more advanced disruption techniques, stating that they are “testing different mechanisms to disrupt the quality of Starlink connections because it’s so important for us.”

Ukraine’s Starlink Dependency

Ukrainian forces are heavily reliant on Starlink for:

  • Delta Battlefield Management

  • Secure communications

  • Drone operations

  • Artillery Coordination & Precision Strikes

  • Cybersecurity & Intelligence Sharing

  • Logistics & Command Networks

Battlefield Management

The Ukrainian Armed Forces primarily rely on the Delta Battlefield Management System (BMS) for battlefield transparency.

Delta is a command-and-control (C2) system that provides real-time situational awareness to military units. It integrates intelligence, reconnaissance, and operational data into a single platform.

Delta allows commanders and frontline troops to see a live, dynamic map of the battlefield, displaying friendly and enemy positions. The system integrates data from drones, reconnaissance units, satellites, and electronic warfare sources.

Delta relies on Starlink and other satellite internet providers to transmit battlefield data in real-time.

Edited Image of Ukraine President Zelenskyy and Elon Musk with Starlink logo.

Secure Communication

Starlink’s strong signal encryption facilitates secure communications between frontline units, command centers, and logistics support facilities. Terrestrial and cellular networks are much more easily degraded or destroyed by Russian strikes.

Drone Warfare 

Ukraine extensively uses aerial drones for surveillance, artillery targeting, and even attack missions. Many drones rely on Starlink for real-time control and data transmission.

Ukrainian sea drone operations are also heavily reliant on Starlink for high bandwidth video stream communication.

Artillery Coordination & Precision Strikes

Field units use Starlink to relay real-time intelligence and guide precision artillery and HIMARS strikes.

Cybersecurity & Intelligence Sharing

Ukraine uses Starlink to share intelligence with Western allies and coordinate cyber operations. It also helps secure digital infrastructure against Russian cyberattacks.

Logistics & Command Networks

Troop movements, resupply missions, and even medical evacuations rely on digital communication, which Starlink supports.

Impact Of Starlink Shutdown

The Starlink shutdown will disrupt Ukrainian forces’ operation across the spectrum. It will force Ukrainian forces to rely on more vulnerable radio and cellular communication networks, which Russia can jam or intercept.

Ukrainian drone operations would be weakened.

Many Ukrainian large and long-range drones rely exclusively on Starlink communications. Hybrid drones, for example, fly autonomously to their target area like cruise missiles and then switch to FPV (First Pilot View) mode to facilitate target recognition and precision attack by a remote human pilot.

The Palianytsia drone is an example of a hybrid drone. By combining autonomous cruise capabilities with FPV manual control, it can more effectively bypass electronic warfare (EW) countermeasures en route than traditional FPV drones.

FPV control and targeting requires high-bandwidth video stream communication

Ukraine uses medium-sized, medium-altitude, long-endurance drones capable of carrying Starlink terminals for battlefield reconnaissance. These drones provide real-time targeting data for precision strikes, which would become slower and less accurate without real-time data transmission.

Difficulty in receiving and transmitting battlefield data would hinder coordination with NATO and Western allies.

Long-range Sea Drone operations have enabled Ukraine to exercise control over much of the Black Sea despite Russia’s Black Sea Fleet  (BSF). The threat from Ukrainian sea drones prevented the Russian BSF from disrupting Ukrainian grain exports despite Russia’s withdrawal from the UN Black Sea Grain Initiative.

Without Starlink, Ukraine would be forced to cede much of its dominance over the Western regions of the Black Sea.

Conclusion

It is highly unlikely that the U.S. will shut down Starlink in Ukraine. Beyond the negative optics of pressuring a key ally, such a move would disrupt U.S. intelligence and military operations in the region.

Several factors make a shutdown impractical:

  • U.S. / NATO Personnel in Ukraine – U.S. and NATO forces play an active role in managing MIM-104 Patriot missile systems and HIMARS launchers.

  • Delta Battlefield Management System – U.S. / NATO airborne ISR assets provide intelligence to Delta BMS, which relies on Starlink for real-time data transmission.

If Starlink were shut down, Ukrainian forces would lose key advantages but remain operational due to alternative satellite-based communication systems. While the impact would be significant but not crippling, certain capabilities would suffer more than others.

Most Affected Ukrainian Capabilities:

  • Long-Range Aerial Drone Attacks – Starlink enables real-time control and data relay for long-range UAVs.

  • Maritime Drone Strikes – Ukrainian naval drones use Starlink for extended-range operations in the Black Sea.

While a shutdown would strain Ukrainian operations, it would not be a decisive blow to their warfighting capability.

AfriPrime App link:  FREE to download...

https://www.amazon.com/Africircle-AfriPrime/dp/B0D2M3F2JT

 

Pesquisar
Categorias
Leia Mais
Outro
Elan The Emperor: Your Exclusive 4/5 BHK Luxury Home in Sector 106, Dwarka Expressway
If you're looking for a residence that combines exclusivity, opulence, and cutting-edge design,...
Por Harshit_Pandey 2025-02-03 10:16:31 0 928
News
Lebanese military deploys troops to more southern border regions
Lebanese armed forces were deploying to several more villages in southern Lebanon on Monday,...
Por Ikeji 2025-01-28 18:01:59 0 1K
Outro
Best Billboard Advertising in New York & Miami
Billboard advertising is a powerful marketing tool that ensures high visibility and brand...
Por merleshay 2025-03-21 07:22:20 0 952
Health
Effective Homeopathic Approach to Kidney Health by Bharat Homeopathy
Kidney diseases have become increasingly common, affecting millions of people worldwide. The...
Por bharathomeopathy 2025-03-21 06:53:07 0 849
Health
The Future of Heart Care is Global: Ventricular Assist Devices Market Trends Across Continents
Ventricular Assist Devices Market accounted for USD 1,726 Million in 2019 and it is expected to...
Por akshada 2024-02-22 09:57:56 0 3K