The BBC should not trust Hamas’s death figures

0
2كيلو بايت

I had a moving conversation on Friday with my friend Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, a political analyst from Gaza who had lost 31 members of his family in the war. This was for the Jewish Chronicle podcast, so there was a certain formality, but at the end I found myself blurting out that I wanted to give him a hug.

Ahmed and I have some differences, but we agree profoundly on the fundamentals. All human lives are precious, all death is tragic and peace is the only goal worth pursuing. This dovetails with the desire not to allow the jihadis of Hamas to manipulate public opinion in the West.

This week, it was reported that 40,000 people have been killed in Gaza. The coverage was filled with the sleight-of-hand with which we have become familiar, insinuating that the Israelis are the liars and butchers, not Hamas. Yolande Knell, the BBC’s Middle East correspondent, opened her story by attributing the 40,000 figure to the “Hamas-run health ministry”. Fine. But she didn’t report the reason this mattered: these figures are deeply unreliable.

There was some discussion of this buried further down, but how hard would it have been to write at the start, “some analysts have doubted the veracity of figures produced by Hamas”? The atmosphere of any story is created by what reporters omit or relegate, as well as what they include.

AfriPrime App link:  FREE to download...

https://www.amazon.com/Africircle-AfriPrime/dp/B0D2M3F2JT

Take these two lines from the BBC: “The ministry’s figures for the number of people killed do not differentiate between civilians and fighters. However, its breakdown of identified reported fatalities say a majority are children, women or elderly people.”

For one thing, analysis of the Hamas “women and children” statistics by the data scientist Professor Abraham Wyner and multidisciplinary academics Tom Simpson, Lewi Stone and Gregory Rose exposed them as laughably implausible.

Their findings received much coverage at the time. This would have been relevant, no?

Moreover, did it not occur to the BBC to wonder how “a majority” of the dead could be “children, women or elderly people”?

Where were all the men? Or was the Mossad singling out the frail and infirm for assassination?

There is an obvious answer.

Most of the male casualties were Hamas terrorists because they are who Israel has been targeting. Which brings me to a further point. The BBC built the story around Hamas’s figures while ignoring Israel’s announcement that at least 17,000 jihadis have been killed in Gaza.

Even taking the most cynical estimate of Israel’s figures and the most generous approach to Hamas, the two combine to produce a combatant-to-civilian casualty ratio of 1:2. The true figure is likely to be closer to 1:1. Remarkably, this was achieved on a battlefield that was designed to provoke civilian deaths for propaganda purposes. Or have we forgotten that one side in this war tries to protect innocent life, while the other side sacrifices it?

When the RAF joined the Americans, Kurds and Iraqis to destroy Islamic State in Mosul, 2.5 civilians were killed for every combatant. The UN’s global average is nine civilian deaths to every fighter.

Israel, therefore, is protecting the innocent better than any other country. Even a single death is a matter of anguish. My friend Ahmed knows this better than most.

Yet this is war and it flows from the depravity of Hamas.

So much of the reporting paints a picture that avoids overt lies but allows a cloud of bloodthirstiness to settle over the democracy while the terrorists are portrayed as the victims. This is why many people are turning away from “mainstream media”.

That is dangerous.

Top Hamas official ends CNN interview when asked about civilian deaths in Gaza

AfriPrime App link:  FREE to download...

https://www.amazon.com/Africircle-AfriPrime/dp/B0D2M3F2JT

إعلان مُمول
البحث
إعلان مُمول
الأقسام
إقرأ المزيد
News
Knee Hyaluronic Acid Injections Market, Opportunities, Trends and Future Outlook By 2032
Knee Hyaluronic Acid Injections Market Overview The Knee Hyaluronic Acid Injections...
بواسطة davidblogs30 2025-02-20 07:19:04 0 1كيلو بايت
Networking
Why Do Universities Need the Best PPC Service in India?
In today’s digital era, universities are competing to attract students in an increasingly...
بواسطة marketingworld 2025-03-05 12:45:01 0 2كيلو بايت
أخرى
Ammolite History, Meaning, Healing Properties, Facts, Benefits, and Uses
These ammonites lived on this planet during the Cretaceous period, and to be specific, about 65...
بواسطة Shivani123 2024-08-23 09:10:27 0 2كيلو بايت
Shopping
Hood by air hoodie
When it comes to streetwear, **Hood By Air** has consistently set the standard for innovative...
بواسطة lunaevergreen 2024-09-26 00:46:15 0 2كيلو بايت
Health
Basil Extract
Benefits Of Holy Basil Extract Stress Relief Basil Extract: Discover the potent benefits and...
بواسطة naturalchemist8 2024-07-18 13:06:24 0 2كيلو بايت
إعلان مُمول
google-site-verification: google037b30823fc02426.html