The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) was indeed established to promote regional stability, economic cooperation, and peace among its member states. However, the South China Sea dispute, particularly China’s extensive territorial claims, poses a significant challenge to ASEAN’s ability to maintain stability in the region.

Understanding the South China Sea Dispute

1. China’s Claims:

   • "Nine-Dash Line": China claims nearly 90% of the South China Sea under what is known as the "Nine-Dash Line," a demarcation that China asserts as historical. This claim overlaps with the exclusive economic zones (EEZs) of several ASEAN member states, including the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, and Brunei.
   • Strategic and Economic Importance: The South China Sea is one of the world's busiest maritime trade routes, rich in natural resources, including oil and natural gas. Control over the sea has significant strategic and economic implications, motivating China’s assertive stance.

2. ASEAN’s Role and Challenges:

   • Diplomatic and Regional Stability: ASEAN was created to foster regional cooperation and maintain peace, but it is not a military alliance. Its principle of non-interference and decision-making by consensus can limit its ability to take strong, collective action on sensitive issues like the South China Sea dispute.
   • Diverse Member Interests: ASEAN members have different levels of economic and political relations with China. Some countries, like Cambodia and Laos, are more aligned with China and may be less inclined to support confrontational stances, while others, like the Philippines and Vietnam, are directly affected by China's claims and actions in the South China Sea. This diversity makes it difficult for ASEAN to present a united front.
   • Balancing Act: ASEAN aims to maintain good relations with China, given its significant economic influence in the region. Simultaneously, ASEAN seeks to protect the sovereignty and territorial rights of its member states. This balancing act often results in carefully worded diplomatic statements and the avoidance of direct confrontation.

AfriPrime App link:  FREE to download...

https://www.amazon.com/Africircle-AfriPrime/dp/B0D2M3F2JT

Why China’s Claims Persist Despite ASEAN’s Existence

1. Power Dynamics:

   • China’s Rising Influence: China is a major global power with significant military and economic capabilities. Its growing influence in the region allows it to assert its claims despite opposition from ASEAN countries and international criticism. China’s economic clout also enables it to exert pressure on individual ASEAN countries, making it harder for the organization to take a firm stance against China.

2. Lack of Strong Enforcement Mechanisms:

   • ASEAN’s Limitations: ASEAN’s consensus-based approach and non-binding agreements mean that it lacks the enforcement mechanisms to compel China to alter its stance. While ASEAN can issue statements and engage in diplomatic dialogue, it cannot force China to back down from its claims.
   • International Law: In 2016, an international tribunal under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) ruled in favor of the Philippines, rejecting China’s claims. However, China rejected the ruling and continues its activities in the South China Sea. The lack of a global enforcement mechanism for such rulings further complicates the situation.

3. China’s Strategic Calculations:

   • Military Presence: China has established a significant military presence in the South China Sea, including the construction of artificial islands and military installations. This presence is a way for China to assert control and deter other claimants.
   • Diplomatic Maneuvering: China often engages in bilateral negotiations with individual ASEAN countries rather than addressing the issue through ASEAN as a whole. This tactic allows China to leverage its influence more effectively and avoid dealing with a unified ASEAN stance.

The South China Sea dispute exemplifies the complexities and limitations ASEAN faces in maintaining regional stability, especially when confronted by a powerful neighbor like China. While ASEAN was created to promote peace and stability, its ability to resolve or mitigate the South China Sea dispute is constrained by its structural limitations, the diverse interests of its member states, and the broader geopolitical dynamics involving China. Despite these challenges, ASEAN continues to play a crucial role in facilitating dialogue and preventing the escalation of conflicts, even if it cannot fully resolve them.

AfriPrime App link:  FREE to download...

https://www.amazon.com/Africircle-AfriPrime/dp/B0D2M3F2JT